| Name | Term |
|---|---|
| Terence "T.K." Lindsay | 2024 |
| Liam Lynch | 2023 |
| Patrick Lynch | 2021-2022 |
| Luke Cihak | 2020 |
| Aidan Campbell | 2019 |
| Jeromy Hafer | 2018 |
| Ethan Lewis | 2017 |
| Christopher Kelly | 2016 |
| Timothy Reppert | 2015 |
| Kieron Pleis | 2014 |
| Spencer Robbins | 2014 |
| Benjamin Lambert | 2013 |
| Sean Bobbie | 2012 |
| Kyle Hallowell | 2011 |
| Jeremy Slocum | 2010 |
| Brian Johnson | 2009 |
| John Bickel | 2005-2008 |
| Peter McPhillips | 2004-2005 |
| James Price Jr. | 2003-2004 |
| Ryan Edmonds | 2002-2003 |
| Michael P. Hilferty | 2001-2002 |
| Jonathan Alessi | 2000-2001 |
| Matthew McGill | 1999-2000 |
| George Warren III | 1998-1999 |
| Brian Wallace | 1997-1998 |
| Jeremy Detwiler | 1996-1997 |
| Jason Shepherd | 1995-1996 |
| Antoine Skinner | 1995 |
| Robert Cook | 1994 |
| Brian Fowler | 1993 |
| Jeffrey Aster | 1992 |
| Steven Ranjo | 1991 |
| David King | 1990 |
| Herbert Toplan | 1988-1989 |
| Joseph Sposato | 1988 |
| Frederick Schindler | 1987 |
| Darrell Braxton | 1987 |
| Mark J. Chilutti | 1986 |
| Daniel J. Coyne | 1985 |
| Christopher Higgins | 1984 |
| Michael J. Coyne | 1983 |
| Timothy P. Kelly | 1982 |
| David H. Sirken | 1981 |
| Michael J. Tursi | 1979-1980 |
| Robert F. Novak | 1979 |
| Jeffrey Steinberg | 1978 |
| Morgan P. Thomas | 1977 |
| William Scott III | 1976 |
| Gary Lewis | 1976 |
| Philip M. Hittner | 1975 |
| Allan D. Geller | 1974 |
| Stephen Silverman | 1973 |
| Joel Glickman | 1972 |
| Larry Carson | 1971 |
| Chester Szczepanski | 1969-1970 |
| Gene Lorandeau | 1968 |
| Robert Tomlinson | 1966-1967 |
| Larry Fullerton | 1964-1965 |
| Stanley Vitella | 1963 |
| Joseph A. Zeigler Jr. | 1962 |
| Charles Clarke | 1961 |
| Anthony Schmidt | 1960 |
| Robert A. Dewey | 1959 |
| Andrew Krupczak | 1957-1958 |
| Murray K. Saltzman | 1956 |
| Albert J. Dorley | 1955 |
| Martin L. Leicht | 1954 |
| Roland E. Dubree Sr. | 1953 |
| Dr. Frank B. Johnston | 1952 |
| Louis R. Spealler | 1950-1951 |
| Samuel E. Allen III | 1949 |
| Nathaniel Morgan | 1948 |
| Carl Jeremias Sr. | 1947 |
| Harry Boardman | 1946 |
| William R. Krause | 1945 |
| Robert H. Sehl | 1944 |
| Abraham Durfor | 1943 |
| Roy C. Imsick | 1942 |
| Herbert F. Hertz | 1941 |
| Robert H. Neely | 1940 |
| John Schmus | 1939 |
| Harry C. Imsick Jr. | 1938 |
| George Yamas | 1937 |
| Richard A. Gregory | 1936 |
| George L. Oeste | 1935 |
| William W. Braunwarth | 1933-1934 |
| George H. Keller | 1932 |
| Charles G. Pilkington | 1931 |
| George J. Baker | 1930 |
| Donald H. Ewing | 1929 |
| Leonard L. Tieman | 1928 |
| William S. Pattison | 1927 |
| Joseph N. Pattison III | 1926 |
| Francis C. Schluth | 1925 |
| H. Lloyd Nelson | 1925 |
| Albert L. Borkow | 1924 |
| Alfred C. Nichols | 1923 |
| W. Coulter Gallagher | 1922 |
| Earle W. Stevenson | 1921 |
| Harry A. Yoder | 1920 |
| Howard Seideman | 1919 |
| Raymond Richter | 1917-1918 |
| George Chapman | 1916 |